The Sinking of the White Ship and the Origins of The Anarchy
This Week In History: 25 November 1120
On the night of 25 November 1120, one of the most consequential maritime disasters in medieval Europe unfolded in the cold waters of the English Channel. The loss of the White Ship, a newly built and lavishly appointed vessel intended to carry members of the English royal household from Barfleur to England, resulted not merely in the deaths of more than three hundred passengers but in a crisis of dynastic legitimacy that shaped the political landscape of twelfth-century England. At the centre of the catastrophe was William Adelin, only legitimate son and designated heir of King Henry I, whose drowning precipitated a prolonged period of instability later known as The Anarchy.
The White Ship was regarded as a symbol of royal prestige and power. Commanded by Thomas FitzStephen, whose father had captained Mora, the vessel that brought William the Conqueror to England in 1066, it was chosen by the younger courtiers to be their preferred passage home after the Norman campaign season. Chroniclers suggest that the atmosphere aboard was one of confidence, extravagance, and excess. Contemporary accounts, most notably that of Orderic Vitalis, describe heavy drinking among the crew and passengers, including William Adelin himself, who was only seventeen at the time. The combination of revelry, a night time departure, and an inexperienced or impaired crew appears to have contributed to the disaster.
The ship struck the submerged Quilleboeuf Rock shortly after leaving Barfleur. Efforts to launch the small boat reserved for the prince initially succeeded, but William, hearing the cries of his drowning half-sister Matilda FitzRoy, ordered his attendants to turn back. The rescue attempt proved fatal. The small craft was overwhelmed by desperate survivors clinging to its sides, and William was lost along with nearly all aboard. Only one man, a butcher from Rouen, is reliably recorded to have survived.
The political ramifications were immediate and far-reaching. With the death of William Adelin, Henry I was left without a legitimate male successor. Though he later designated his daughter, also named Matilda, as heir, this decision contravened prevailing expectations of male succession and lacked universal acceptance among the Anglo-Norman nobility. Upon Henry’s death in 1135, his nephew Stephen of Blois seized the throne, securing the support of many leading magnates who were reluctant to acknowledge a female ruler.
Matilda, together with her husband Geoffrey of Anjou, founder of the Plantagenet line, initiated a protracted conflict against Stephen and his supporters to assert her claim to the English throne. The resulting civil war, known as The Anarchy, endured from 1138 to 1153 and had severe consequences, particularly across southern England. Scholars continue to debate the degree to which this period constituted a true collapse of royal governance; nevertheless, the evidence points to marked instability throughout the realm. The Anarchy exposed the precarious nature of medieval succession practices and underscored the deep-seated structural tensions within the Anglo-Norman aristocracy.
I hope you have enjoyed this foray into history. Please subscribe to read more articles like this.
CLICK HERE to read more History and Happenings articles.
Have you discovered The Official Reading Companion and History Briefings for The Chronicles of St Mary’s series by Jodi Taylor?
If you’ve ever found yourself wondering who did what, when, and where in Jodi Taylor’s brilliant Chronicles of St Mary’s series — this is the companion guide you’ve been waiting for.
This guide is a must-have for both dedicated fans and curious newcomers. It contains synopses of every book and short story, detailed floor plans of St Mary’s Institute for Historical Research, History Briefings, chronological jump lists, character information, and more.
Whether you’re brushing up on the timeline or want to immerse yourself further in the chaos and charm of St Mary’s, this guide is your ultimate companion.
CLICK HERE to learn more.